Little Italy Pizza in New York City

Little Italy Pizza
4 /5
50 reviews

169 W 33rd St New York, NY 10001

12126439988

Restaurant Hours

Open Close

Monday 08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday 08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday 08:00 - 17:00

Thursday 00:00 - 17:00

Friday 00:00 - 17:00

Saturday

Sunday

Overview

Little Italy Pizza, 169 W 33rd St New York, NY 10001, New York City

Reviews

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Pizza is vary good. Don't be offended by employees attitudes, also keep in mine that English may not be there first language concentrating on what they're trying to say and busy and trying to get things done. When I was in there the place was wall to wall, and all employees were working vary hard pumping food out as fast as people were ordering.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

We saw a sign with "PIZZA" on it from a distance and decided to stop in. SO glad we did! It was so yummy!! We got chicken bacon ranch, cheese and meat lovers plus garlic knots. All were delicious and made our trip memorable. Because, you know, you HAVE to have NY pizza while in NY, right? Yum. The garlic knots were strong so don't order if you can't handle it. :)Only regret is that we didn't have time to go eat here a 2nd time. Next time, NYC!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

So good! Quick, inexpensive pizza. A great place to stop on the go!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Great place... hooked us up, one of my kids dropped a slice and they were quick to replace it for us... very nice!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

This restaurant is amazing! I've had almost everything on the menu but i love the spicy maninara pizza and meatballs. I've been coming here for a long time but Andrew O. was fantastic! Very attentive and made the experience special. Cheers!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Great place but be warned they do not take reservations. I would suggest making a quick phone call in when you are 20-30 mins away and put yourself on the waiting list. The service was very personable and they made some great recommendations for food choices.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
1/5

Food was dry and not great at all. We didn’t notice how filthy the place was until we tried to find a seat. It’s a very tiny space with too many tables/chairs. I normally don’t write negative reviews, but we were especially ticked off when the manager reached over the couple sitting next to us, wiped off the garbage and crumbs, right onto their laps without saying “excuse me” or apologizing for literally throwing garbage and crumbs onto their laps. Then, when the wife said something to him about it, a whole quarrel started between them, so we left before it got bad. There are plentyyy of better places to get pizza in this area. This spot was pricey for the quality of food, dirty spot and overall poor experience.Response to owner: Your pizza spot is one of the most disgusting places in NYC and I’m ashamed for even trying it out. I will NEVER try it again and I hope everyone reading this avoids it too.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Best pizza I've ever had. 🤩

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
1/5

Be careful about the prices! They will charge you a higher price than what is listed on the store wall and on the online order if you don’t check! Just happened to me a couple minutes ago. The receipt attached is for a pepperoni, mozzarella and white spinach slices. Always ask for the price beforehand and double check with the correct prices. Especially if you are visiting out of town. They are not honest and do not have integrity!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

The BEST pizza in the city! Before I moved to New York I stumbled upon this place while visiting. My friend said “they have the perfect pizza to grease ratio” which is true! The crust is amazing and the same every time I go - classic New York pizza at its finest

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Amazing! The food was incredible. The crust was very thin and crunchy. The staff was just as great. They were so helpful. Little Italy Pizza is the perfect small, cozy environment to enjoy a slice of pizza.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Pizza was very good. If you are looking for a quick slice and don't want to spend to much this is a perfect stop. Staff was friendly and efficient. Not a ton of seating and consistently busy (a good thing), so consider a to go pie, or they offer free delivery.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Great pizza decent service...

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Very crowed! So I got take out.. So good! I'll will be back!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Good pizza, good staff, good location. It's nice to see they making your pizza, the workers are non stop. They are always busy but yet fast. They deliver for free!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Excellent pizza! Whatever they put on the bottom of the pizza is simply amazing! Best Pizza I have ever had, will visit next time I am back in NY. Great prices too!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
3/5

Food is not fresh but the pizza is good once they reheat it in the oven. My calzone was trash. If your going to get anything, a a while pizza. That way it'll be made fresh.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

I have to my if you want a quick good slice of NY pizza this is a good place to go. It is quick, great food, and you get the NY ambiance if you are a tourist. Can't go wrong if you either need to try a NY pizza as a tourist or just want a quick bite of pizza to go.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
1/5

Worst pizza ever! I ordered their lunch special and got 2 pieces of terrible pizza. The bottom was beyond charred and the crust was like charcoal. After 2 bites I went to the counter and asked for a refund and they kept trying to offer me a different slice or something else when I just wanted my money back. When I asked for a manager the old man spoke English with an accent so heavy I could only understand every other word. I just left my food and walked out. Worst pizza place I have ever seen, they don't even let you get a refund for bad service.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

I never seen a pizza so big in my life. Thanks to my cousin for taking my husband and I their. Loved it

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

A very good pizza. Much better than expected.A very good opportunity in this central location to get something to eat at a fair price.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Excelent pizza! Good service!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

The best NYC pizza I have ever had! The crust was so crispy on the bottom, chewy in the middle, perfect amount of marinara with hot mozzarella cheese. Loved it! Facility is tiny and quaint perfect for a quick bite. Thank you so much.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

The long line sold us and it moved fast. When i saw an Empire State Building worker buy a slice, I knew it was going to be good. Great place for a quick slice!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

On our trip to NYC we had to have some New York Pizza. Came here after visiting the Empire State Building (across the street) The Pizza was everything I ever imagined NY Style pizza to taste. The Crust was thin and Crispy and the cheese and pepperoni was tasty. Will definitely be back to Little Italy Pizza when i come back to New York. Need something like this here in the West Coast.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
1/5

Pizza is delicious but the guy in the pay spot (this afternoon)was rude and he denied to apply us the offer charging us with the drinks while the offer was displayed in and outside the place. Employees like these make places a lot worse.By the way the lack of cleaning is disgusting.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Really great pizza! We had a few different places while we were in NYC and this was by far my favorite. I wish I would have found it earlier, I probably would have just had this pizza multiple times!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
2/5

The pizza is good, the only thing is that the workers weren’t wearing masks when preparing our food. Literally the guy cutting it was wearing a chin strap and the guy boxing the pizza had his nose hanging out. Gross during a pandemic

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Solid spot! Great atmosphere, beautiful interior, amazing food (tried the walnut bread app with burrata, a pizza, and the Friday Night Special: Lasagne alla Bolognese) and an incredible yet simple dessert (vanilla gelato with olive oil & salt). Wow. Loved it.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
1/5

👎🏼👎🏼 CAUTION: go somewhere else. We ordered a few times from them and pizza was usually good. The last pizza they sent only took 14 minutes to make and deliver. They sent an old and cold pizza. They threw it in the oven for a few minutes and then delivered it as if it was fresh. The pizza was not edible. Upon complaining they lied and said it was fresh. They would not refund the $35 for a medium pizza delivered. I would urge everyone to be careful and go with a restaurant that is honest and does not lie. We are happy to pay up for a good $35 medium pizza. But they have no Shane in lying and in delivering old and cold pizza. In this case save yourself the money and buy a frozen pizza at Duane Read it CVS.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Very good place to go, eat. There are nice people and good service. That is the best pizza place I've ever went in New York city.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Was perfect for a late night bite to eat with a beer before heading to a bar.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Fun and happy, It was a Friday night and packed but we managed to get seats in a fair amount of time

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

The pizza tasted great, it had a really nice and crispy crust, and it came out quick. I got the Margherita and the Chicken Riccotta slices, and they filled me up quick! The prices seemed very reasonable too.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

The ambiance at this Valencia classic is really fun. The whole restaurant is done in dark wood and the bar has really cool light bulb lights over it. There is usually a wait, but you can call ahead to get your name on the list.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

I work across the street and thought this was a tourist trap but we had THE BESTTTTT pepperoni Sicilian slices from here. It's like 2 lbs of pepperoni on each slice. The crust is thick but soooo tasty and the bottom is nice and crisp. Please look at the pictures, it speaks for itself. It's so dangerous that it is just across the street from my office. We've already had it twice this week.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

A Pizza and Beer oasis just across the street from the front entrance of the Empire State Building. They have an awesome 2 plain Slice & Large Fountain Drink Special for only $6.50(tax included), What a deal! The pizza is slamming! My favorites are the special of course, and the grandma slice.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Good pizza at reasonable prices. They have quite a few tables and seats so it's good if you want to sit down and eat

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Had a Sicilian slice. Tasted nice but nothing special. Would go again but wasn't particularly wowed by the taste.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Little Italy Pizza is a bit of a hidden gem on a quiet corner. The ambiance was satisfying -the place had an overall upscale feel to it. The dimly lit environment and subtle background noise make it easy to enjoy some good food with good company.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Authentic New York pizza. The garlic knots were really good. Hadn't tried them before. Late night food stop on Halloween. Awesome

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

The pizza was fantastic and not expensive. A slice went a long way. Not fancy but very good.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Good food, good price, good service: good place to go. I enjoyed it!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

I'll definitely be back again to try their delicious looking pizzas!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
4/5

Fast service, friendly staff! Closest to Empire state building! You get Decent pizza! Would recommend for a quick bite!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Good pizza and good chicken rolls, if you get the special its 2 slices and a fountain drink for $6.50 ish... and it's right across the street from the empire state building, outside seating avalible and room inside for many tables after covid

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Ordered through the Slice App to be delivered to my hotel. They came at the exact time they said they would (30 min on a Friday night). Pizza was HOT, fresh and delicious. They even have plates and napkins.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Really good pizza. Both locations. And they do that bread crumb thing on the bottom.

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
5/5

Honestly, my favorite pizza in New York.The pepperoni pizza is simply fantastic, add the powdered garlic adds one extra layer of flavor on top of it.And the free refil on the sodas also get that to the top of my list.A must have when in the city!

Little Italy Pizza
- on google
3/5

Good pizza place, less seating available and options are also little less but taste is good.